|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 44-50
Common mental disorders among HIV-uninfected women living in HIV serodiscordant setting: A clinic-based study in Pune, Maharashtra, India
Shrinivas S Darak1, Swapna R Pawar2, Sanjay S Phadke3, Vinay V Kulkarni4
1 Senior Researcher, Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital and Research Centre, Pune, Maharashtra, India
2 Research Assistant, Prayas Health Group, Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital and Research Centre, Pune, Maharashtra, India
3 Honorary Consultant, Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital and Research Centre, Pune, Maharashtra, India
4 Coordinator, Prayas Health Group, Pune, Maharashtra, India
|Date of Web Publication||12-Mar-2019|
Dr. Shrinivas S Darak
Prayas, Amrita Clinic, Karve Road, Sambhaji Bridge Corner, Athawale Corner Building, Deccan Gymkhana, Pune - 411 004, Maharashtra
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Background: India is home to 2.1 million people living with HIV with an estimated 44% people having an uninfected partner. Living in HIV serodiscordant setting can be stressful, especially for women and can lead to several common mental disorders (CMDs). However, the occurrence of CMD in this population is not studied in India. Objectives: The study aimed to assess the occurrence of CMD in HIV-uninfected women living in HIV serodiscordant setting. A sample of 152 HIV-uninfected women who are wives of HIV-infected men attending an HIV clinic were interviewed by trained interviewers. Methods: The International Classification of Diseases-10 diagnosis of any of the CMDs was done using standard structured diagnostic interview MINI 5.0.0. Current, past, and lifetime occurrence was estimated for various CMDs. Chi-square and point-biserial correlation coefficients were used to understand the relationship between various sociodemographic and HIV-related factors with current CMD. Results: The current, past, and lifetime occurrence of at least one CMD was 35.5%, 49.3%, and 62.5%, respectively. Common diagnoses were mixed anxiety-depressive disorder, major depressive disorder, and posttraumatic stress disorder. Of the women with CMD, 22% had accompanying suicidality. Conclusions: The high rate of occurrence of CMD observed among the study population calls for more attention on the policy and program level to address the mental health needs of this population. Globally, more number of HIV-infected people are now linked to the care. This provides an opportunity to incorporate mental health care into routine HIV care.
Keywords: Common mental disorders, HIV serodiscordance, HIV transmission, India, mental health, posttraumatic stress disorder
|How to cite this article:|
Darak SS, Pawar SR, Phadke SS, Kulkarni VV. Common mental disorders among HIV-uninfected women living in HIV serodiscordant setting: A clinic-based study in Pune, Maharashtra, India. Indian J Public Health 2019;63:44-50
|How to cite this URL:|
Darak SS, Pawar SR, Phadke SS, Kulkarni VV. Common mental disorders among HIV-uninfected women living in HIV serodiscordant setting: A clinic-based study in Pune, Maharashtra, India. Indian J Public Health [serial online] 2019 [cited 2019 May 25];63:44-50. Available from: http://www.ijph.in/text.asp?2019/63/1/44/253882
| Introduction|| |
Globally, there were approximately 36.7 (34.0–39.8) million people living with HIV (PLHA) at the end of 2015, including around 1.8 million people becoming newly infected with HIV in that year. Among PLHIV, significant proportions of people live as HIV serodiscordant couples where one among the couple is HIV infected. India is home to around 2.1 million PLHA, of which almost 1.3 million (59.5%) are men. It is estimated that around 44% of HIV-infected individuals in India have uninfected partners. This implies that more than half a million women are living in HIV serodiscordant relationship in India.
Majority of the studies carried out among serodiscordant couples have focused entirely on the prevention of HIV transmission to uninfected partners. There is little focus on the mental health needs of the uninfected partners.,,, While there is increasing research highlighting the importance of addressing mental health needs of HIV-infected people to improve treatment outcomes, there is lack of understanding of mental health needs of uninfected partner in serodiscordant settings.
Living in serodiscordant relationship, particularly in long-term relationship, can generate unique stressors adversely affecting the mental health. Partners in such setting struggle to maintain relationship with constant fear of HIV transmission. Dilemma of altered reproductive possibilities, shifts in patterns of sexuality and emotional intimacy, stigma and discrimination, coping with thoughts of impending illness, lack of social support, addiction, financial stress, etc., can act as additional stressors.,, In Indian sociocultural context, where monogamous marital relationship is a norm and is considered a moral obligation, there can be strong sense of betrayal upon disclosure of HIV-positive status of a spouse. Majority of the people living in serodiscordant setting in India are women. The role of caregiving is inevitably conferred to women adding to the burden. Being women and spouse caregivers add to the vulnerabilities to this population.,, The physical and psychological effects of long-term informal caregiving have been widely documented in the literature, resulting in various common mental disorders (CMDs), especially depression and anxiety.,
The term CMDs refer to a range of anxiety and depressive disorders. CMDs significantly contribute to the global burden of disease. It is estimated that 4.4% of the world's population (322 million people) suffer from depressive disorders and 3.6% (264 million people) from anxiety disorders with many people experiencing both conditions simultaneously. In India, different studies documented high prevalence of CMDs in general population. A recent (2015–2016) community-based national mental health survey in India reported that 10% of the country's population experience CMDs with depression being the most common. Among different factors, chronic stress, long-term illness such as diabetes, cancers, and HIV have been causally linked with CMDs. Not only people suffering with the illness but also those who are affected (family care providers) are at higher risk of experiencing CMDs.,,
This study sought to assess the occurrence of CMDs among HIV-uninfected women who are wives of HIV-infected men in selected HIV discordant setting in Pune, Maharashtra. In the context of HIV, where counseling services are already available for HIV-infected people, adequate understanding of the prevalence of CMDs among HIV-uninfected partners would be helpful for care providers and policy-makers to design appropriate strategies to address this issue.
| Materials and Methods|| |
Study design and setting
This cross-sectional study was conducted at a specialized HIV clinic run by a nongovernmental organization in Pune, Maharashtra, India. HIV-infected and affected people from all over the state of Maharashtra access services at the clinic.
Sample size and study population
Considering CMD prevalence of 10% in general population (as reported in the recent National Mental Health Survey of India) and 95% confidence interval (CI), the estimated sample size was 166. In the stipulated period, we could recruit 152 participants in the study. The study participants were purposively selected HIV-uninfected women, whose HIV-infected partners were accessing care at the clinic. HIV-infected men living in serodiscordant setting were identified through their clinical records. These men were informed about the study during their clinical visit in the study period, and their written assent to contact their wives was sought. Women were then contacted and informed about the study. If women agreed to participate, they were invited to clinic for interview. Fixed amount of money was given to them for their travel expenses, depending on the distance of their home from the clinic. Written informed consent was obtained from the women before interview. HIV testing was carried out for women consenting to participate in the study before any data collection.
Women who were tested negative for HIV, who were aware of the husband's HIV-positive status for more than 6 months, and who were willing to provide written consent were eligible to participate. Women having a prior history of known psychiatric illness and women who were not living with husband for 6 months or more were considered not eligible to participate in the study.
The data were collected from April 2015 to September 2016. All eligible women were interviewed by trained researchers and a clinical psychologist in face-to-face interview. The trained clinical psychologist administered structured diagnostic interview, MINI 5.0.0. Data were also collected on the burden experienced by women after the diagnosis of husband's HIV in the form of change in family and social relationship, negative feelings toward husband, impact on physical and emotional health, burden on fear of HIV transmission, and perceived financial burden. Routine physical examination was performed by clinician, and vital parameters were noted. Hemogram, routine blood sugar levels, and test for thyroid function (thyroid-stimulating hormone) were performed free of cost for every woman to exclude the common biological causes of psychosomatic symptoms.
Data were entered by trained data entry operators into Epi-Info (version 7) Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in (Atlanta, Georgia, US).
Identification of common mental disorders
A validated diagnostic interview using Mini International Neuropsychiatry Interview 5.0.0 (MINI) was conducted to identify women having CMD. MINI was designed as a brief structured interview for the major axis I psychiatric disorders in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-IV and International Classification of Diseases-10. The results of validation and reliability studies show that the MINI has acceptably high validation and reliability scores. MINI is useful to diagnose current as well as past CMDs. Timeframes of current and past diagnoses were used as per MINI. Lifetime diagnosis was done when there was at least one CMD at least once in lifetime. Additional module for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in the past was developed and administered by trained psychologist considering the unique need of the study population.
Statistical analysis was done using SPSS 16 statistical software and Microsoft Excel 2010. The occurrence of CMDs in the study population is estimated by analyzing the proportion of women diagnosed as having CMD as per the MINI 5.0.0. Relationship was assessed between different sociodemographic, general health condition parameters, HIV-related factors, and CMDs by univariate analysis. Univariate analysis was done using Chi-square test.
The study was approved by the Independent Ethics Committees for Research of Prayas (registration number: ECR/146/Indt/MH/2014). Women diagnosed with CMD were informed about appropriate care services and were assisted in accessing these services. Consent for appropriate mode of contacting the women to inform her blood test report was sought, and blood reports were informed accordingly.
| Results|| |
From April 2015 to September 2016, 344 men living in HIV serodiscordant setting were informed about the study, out of which 291 (85%) men provided assent to contact their wife at the first visit. However, 79 (27%) men who first provided assent later suggested that they or their partner were not willing to participate in the project. At the end, 154 (45% of the total informed) women were seen at the clinic of which 2 were not eligible to participate and 152 completed the interview.
Among the women enrolled in the study, the mean age was 40.1 years (standard deviation ± 8.06). The women had mainly come from Pune district (65.1%). Majority of the women (61.2%) were from upper middle socioeconomic strata which were determined using Kuppuswamy's scale. Little more than half of the women (53.3%) were doing some or the other remunerated work and half of those who were working were self-employed, the most common occupations being farming and tailoring. Husbands of all except one were taking antiretroviral drug therapy. Most of the women (70.4%) knew about husband's HIV status for more than 5 years at the time of interview. [Table 1] gives the sociodemographic profile of the women and [Table 2] depicts HIV-related characteristics of the husbands.
|Table 1: Sociodemographic characteristics of the study population and their association with the common mental disorder|
Click here to view
|Table 2: HIV related characteristics and common mental disorders of the study population|
Click here to view
Occurrence of common mental disorder
Current common mental disorder
Of the 152 women in the study, 54 women had at least one current CMD as per the MINI diagnostic interview, amounting to the occurrence of current CMD as 35.5% (95% CI – 28–44) (Clopper–Pierson exact method) [Table 3]. The most common diagnosis was mixed anxiety-depressive disorder (MADD) [Table 4]. Of the 18 women suffering from MADD, 8 women were suffering for at least 4 years. Current major depressive episode (MDE) was reported among 10 women. Of these, 4 women were suffering for >18 months. PTSD was seen in 5 women, of whom 3 women were suffering for >5 years. The MINI diagnostic interview provides additional information on suicidality which was reported by 12 women as accompanying symptom with other disorders. Of these, 3 women had high suicidality. Out of those women who had current CMD, 8 women were found to be in significant distress as assessed by clinical psychologist and were prescribed medication by a psychiatrist.
|Table 3: Occurrence of the common mental disorder among human immunodeficiency virus-uninfected women in serodiscordant setting|
Click here to view
|Table 4: Frequency of occurrence of different mental disorders among human immunodeficiency virus-uninfected women in serodiscordant setting|
Click here to view
Many women perceived burden of caring for husband. Half of them (n = 76) reported negative feelings toward husband, 49% reported burden of change in family and social relationships due to husband's HIV diagnosis, and 36% reported the impact of husband's HIV diagnosis on their emotional health.
Past common mental disorder
History of symptoms of CMDs investigated through MINI revealed that 49.3% (95% CI 41–58) of the women had suffered from symptoms of at least one of the CMDs in the past. The most common disorder was MDE. MDE was reported in 64 (42.1%) women of whom 19 women suffered for more than a year. PTSD was seen in 23 (15.1%) women, and for all of them, the onset was linked to the disclosure of husband's HIV-positive status to them. Of these 23 women, 7 continued to suffer for more than a year.
The occurrence of CMD at least once after disclosure of husband's HIV status was 56.5% (95% CI 48–65) excluding 9 women who had suffered from symptoms of CMD in the past but before the disclosure.
There were 35 (23%) women who had suffered from one or more CMDs in the past, had complete recovery, and were suffering again at the time of data collection. The lifetime occurrence, proportion of women who had suffered from any of the CMDs at least once in their lifetime, was 62.5% (95% CI 54–70).
| Discussion|| |
The occurrence of current CMD among HIV-uninfected women living in HIV serodiscordant setting in Maharashtra is as high as 35.5%. While 49.3% of women have had CMD in the past, more than half of the women have suffered from CMD at least once after the disclosure of HIV status of the husband to them. The observed pattern shows substantially high occurrence of PTSD, and other mood and anxiety disorders accompanied by suicidality.
The observed rate of occurrence of CMD in the study population appears to be significantly higher than that found among the general population in India (10%). The rate CMD in this group is almost comparable to the reported CMD prevalence among HIV-infected people, suggesting the severity of stress experienced by uninfected women who are spouses of infected men. Almost similar rate of depression (34.5%) was reported by a recent study (2017) from North of Karnataka, India, among 145 HIV-infected women. This suggests similar vulnerability of HIV-infected as well as affected women for experiencing mental disorders. Spouses among all the informal caregivers of HIV-infected people in India seem to have higher level of stress and stigma, resulting in higher rate of depression and anxiety.
HIV-infected husbands of majority women who participated in the study were taking antiretroviral treatment and were apparently asymptomatic. The stress and the burden expressed by many women were related to the emotional impact of knowing husband's HIV status, the feeling of betrayal, concern about future, and to lesser extent about the physical exhaustion of caring for the husband. This also clearly suggests that even with increasing antiretroviral treatment access to HIV-infected persons and significant improvement in their physical health, the emotional impact of knowing partner's HIV status persists, making the uninfected partner at risk of mental disorders.
The observed pattern of CMDs also differs from that seen in the general population. Many women suffered from CMD for a considerable time, suggesting continuation of stress after knowing husband's HIV status. The substantially high occurrence of PTSD around the time of disclosure of husband's HIV status suggests that knowing husband's HIV status is nothing less than experiencing a personal disaster. The link between PTSD and HIV has been previously reported by Neigh et al. (2016) who discussed biological mechanisms which may contribute to coexistence and potential interactions of these two disorders. However, the findings of this study among HIV-uninfected women suggest that knowing about HIV status of husband could itself act as a severe trauma. The adverse psychological reaction could range from mild transitional emotional distress to more enduring and impairing psychopathology such as PTSD.
Apparently the sociodemographic characteristics of the women do not seem to have any correlation with CMDs, suggesting that the vulnerabilities of these women and the possible coping strategies are beyond the sociodemographic differences. The gender differences  and disadvantages with respect to vulnerability to experience mental health issues are known in the literature where women are reported to have higher CMDs., Further research is needed to identify the “protective” factors helping women to cope with the trauma and “risk” factors which act as stressors and lead to psychopathological effects.
One of the limitations of the study could be representativeness bias inherent in the clinic-based studies; however, community-based studies among HIV-infected and affected population are difficult. The characteristics of those women who participated and who (women or their husbands) refused to participate could not be compared, thus making it difficult to comment on the occurrence of CMD among those who refused to participate.
| Conclusion|| |
Globally, more number of HIV-infected people are now linked to the care. While there is an acknowledgment of mental health needs of PLHIV, integrating mental health in routine HIV care is far from reality. In case of serodiscordant couples, there is no systemic inclusion of uninfected partners in the care, and focus is on mere prevention of transmission of infection. The high occurrence of CMD observed among the study population calls for more attention on the policy and program level to address the mental health needs of this population. Extrapolating this rate of occurrence to an estimated 5,72,000 HIV-uninfected women living in HIV serodiscordant setting in India results in more than 200,000 women currently suffering from some CMD. With increasing number of people being tested for HIV and are aware of their HIV status, this number can be expected to increase further. High emphasis on linking HIV-infected people to care and treatment facilities is an opportunity to strengthen mental health care to them and to systematically link and retain their uninfected partners in the care. There is an urgent need to identify and implement culturally appropriate  cost-effective interventions. Interventions delivered by health counselors  and with the use of technology  should be considered.
We sincerely thank all our participants who in spite of knowing the sensitivity of the topic, participated in the study. We would like to thank Dr. Swapnil Gadhave for his crucial contribution in the initial phase of the study. We are grateful to Mr. Manik Pardhe and Ms. Manisha Shinde, the counselors at Amrita Clinic, for their contribution in recruitment and pre- and post-HIV test counseling of the study participants; Ms. Madhuri Nalawde, a clinical psychologist, for her contribution in conducting MINI diagnostics interviews; and Ms. Pallavi Kadam for data collection and management.
Financial support and sponsorship
This study was financially supported by Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR), New Delhi, under grant number (GIA/51/2014/DHR).
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Chemaitelly H, Abu-Raddad LJ. Characterizing HIV epidemiology in stable couples in Cambodia, the Dominican Republic, Haiti, and India. Epidemiol Infect 2016;144:90-6.
National AIDS Control Organisation & National Institute of Medical Statistics. India HIV Estimations 2015 Technical Report. New Delhi: Ministry of Health and Family Welfare; 2015.
Burgess R, Campbell C. Contextualising women's mental distress and coping strategies in the time of AIDS: A rural South African case study. Transcult Psychiatry 2014;51:875-903.
Kipp W, Nkosi TM. Factors associated with the self-reported health status of female caregivers of AIDS patients. West J Nurs Res 2008;30:20-33.
Orner P. Psychosocial impacts on caregivers of people living with AIDS. AIDS Care 2006;18:236-40.
Santiesteban Y, Castro M, Calvo M. Mental health of primary caregivers for children and adolescents with HIV/AIDS in cuba. MEDICC Rev 2012;14:30-4.
Kaaya S, Eustache E, Lapidos-Salaiz I, Musisi S, Psaros C, Wissow L. Grand challenges: Improving HIV treatment outcomes by integrating interventions for co-morbid mental illness. PLoS Med 2013;10:e1001447.
Beckerman NL, Letteney S, Lorber K. Key emotional issues for couples of mixed HIV status. Soc Work Health Care 2000;31:25-41.
Jibat N, Nigussie B, Tesfaye S. Socioeconomic challenges and coping mechanisms of HIV serodiscordant couples in Jimma town, Oromia/Ethiopia. Eur Sci J 2014;10:158-75.
Lua Pl, Mustapha N, Abdullah R, Abdul Rahman AK. The Experiences and challenges in caring for hiv/aids patients: A qualitative exploration among muslim family caregivers in Terengganu, Malaysia. AEAN J Psychiatry Ment Health 2014;15:10.
Chandra PS, Satyanarayana VA. Gender disadvantage and common mental disorders in women. Int Rev Psychiatry 2010;22:513-24.
Kohli R, Purohit V, Karve L, Bhalerao V, Karvande S, Rangan S, et al.
Caring for caregivers of people living with HIV in the family: A response to the HIV pandemic from two urban Slum communities in Pune, India. PLoS One 2012;7:e44989.
Pinquart M, Sörensen S. Spouses, adult children, and children-in-law as caregivers of older adults: A meta-analytic comparison. Psychol Aging 2011;26:1-4.
Schulz R, Sherwood PR. Physical and mental health effects of family caregiving. Am J Nurs 2008;108:23-7.
Ghate MV, Marcotte TD, Rangnekar HD, Meyer R, Sakamoto M, Mehendale SM. Depressive symptoms in spouses of HIV infected individuals: A study of HIV uninfected caregivers in Pune, India. Open J Psychiatry 2015;5:1-6.
Pirraglia PA, Bishop D, Herman DS, Trisvan E, Lopez RA, Torgersen CS, et al.
Caregiver burden and depression among informal caregivers of HIV-infected individuals. J Gen Intern Med 2005;20:510-4.
Goldberg D, Huxley P. Common Mental Disorders: A Biosocial Model. London: Tavistock/Routledge; 1992.
World Health Organization. Depression and Other Common Mental Disorders: Global Health Estimates. Geneva: WHO; 2017.
Gururaj G, Varghese M, Benegal V, Rao GN, Pathak K, Singh LK, et al
. National Mental Health Survey-2015–16 Summary. Bengaluru: National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences (NIMHANS); 2016.
Amorim P, Lecrubier Y, Weiller E, Hergueta T, Sheehan D. DSM-IH-R psychotic disorders: Procedural validity of the mini international neuropsychiatric interview (MINI). Concordance and causes for discordance with the CIDI. Eur Psychiatry 1998;13:26-34.
Gururaj M. Kuppuswamy's Socio-Economic Status Scale – A revision of income parameter For 2014. Int J Recent Trends Sci Technol 2014;11:1-2.
Chibanda D, Cowan FM, Healy JL, Abas M, Lund C. Psychological interventions for common mental disorders for people living with HIV in low- and middle-income countries: Systematic review. Trop Med Int Health 2015;20:830-9.
Hiremath SB, Desai M. A study on prevalence and correlates of depression among women living with human immunodeficiency virus/acquired immune deficiency syndrome in North Karnataka. Ind Psychiatry J 2017;26:188-93.
] [Full text]
Khan R, Pai K, Kulkarni V, Ramapuram J. Depression, anxiety, stress and stigma in informal caregivers of people living with HIV (PLHIV). AIDS Care 2018;30:722-6.
Neigh GN, Rhodes ST, Valdez A, Jovanovic T. PTSD co-morbid with HIV: Separate but equal, or two parts of a whole? Neurobiol Dis 2016;92:116-23.
Li L, Liang LJ, Lin C, Ji G, Xiao Y. Gender differences in depressive symptoms among HIV-positive concordant and discordant heterosexual couples in China. Psychol Women Q 2017;41:89-99.
Chandra PS, Parameshwaran S, Satyanarayana VA, Varghese M, Liberti L, Duggal M, et al.
I have no peace of mind-psychosocial distress expressed by rural women living with HIV in india as part of a mobile health intervention – A qualitative study. Arch Womens Ment Health 2018;21:525-31.
Maitra S, Brault MA, Schensul SL, Schensul JJ, Nastasi BK, Verma RK, et al.
An approach to mental health in low and middle income countries: A case example from urban India. Int J Ment Health 2015;44:215-30.
Patel V, Weiss HA, Chowdhary N, Naik S, Pednekar S, Chatterjee S, et al.
Effectiveness of an intervention led by lay health counsellors for depressive and anxiety disorders in primary care in Goa, India (MANAS): A cluster randomised controlled trial. Lancet 2010;376:2086-95.
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]