|Year : 2014 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 17-21
Epidemiological profile of snake bite in South 24 Parganas district of West Bengal with focus on underreporting of snake bite deaths
Dayalbandhu Majumder1, Abhik Sinha2, Salil Kumar Bhattacharya3, Rama Ram4, Urmila Dasgupta5, A Ram6
1 Medical Officer, Department of Ophthalmology, R.G. Kar Medical College, Kolkata, West Bengal, India
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Community Medicine, R.G. Kar Medical College, Kolkata, West Bengal, India
3 Professor and Head, Department of Community Medicine, Calcutta National Medical College, Kolkata, West Bengal, India
4 Professor and Head, Department of Community Medicine, Kishanganj Medical College, Kishanganj, Bihar, India
5 Associate Professor, Department of Community Medicine, Calcutta National Medical College, Kolkata, West Bengal, India
6 Professor and Head, Department of Pharmacology, Kishanganj Medical College, Kishanganj, Bihar, India
|Date of Web Publication||5-Mar-2014|
281, Dumdum Park, Flat No. C1, 3rd Floor, Kolkata - 700 055, West Bengal
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Background: Snake bite is a neglected public health problem in India. Very few community based epidemiological studies in India have been published so far on this issue. Most of the studies were carried out on hospital data. Previous community-based survey in the state revealed that only 22% snake bite victims attended hospitals. Objectives: The objective of the present study is to find out the epidemiological profile of snake bite in eight blocks of the South 24-Paraganas district of West Bengal and to explore the under reporting of snake bite deaths in health facilities in that area during the study period. Materials and Methods: A retrospective analysis of snake bite data was carried out from a community-based epidemiological survey on 1.9 million populations. This survey was done door-to-door from January 2009 to October 2010 to get epidemiological profile of snake bite of the previous 2 years. The data of direct survey was compared with the official report of the same area to evaluate the hospital-based data with focus on underreporting of snakebite deaths. Results: A total number of snake bite cases as found in the survey in the study area was 4871. There was a huge gap between the two data (direct survey and official data). Only 7.23% snake bite deaths were officially reported. Only 22.19% of the snake bite victims attended the hospitals. Nearly 65.7% of the snake bite deaths were due to common krait bite, most of them occurring in the months of June to September. Conclusions: Official reporting system is still having a huge deficiency in India. Snake bite needs to get more attention from the health authority.
Keywords: Community survey, Official reporting, Snake bite
|How to cite this article:|
Majumder D, Sinha A, Bhattacharya SK, Ram R, Dasgupta U, Ram A. Epidemiological profile of snake bite in South 24 Parganas district of West Bengal with focus on underreporting of snake bite deaths. Indian J Public Health 2014;58:17-21
|How to cite this URL:|
Majumder D, Sinha A, Bhattacharya SK, Ram R, Dasgupta U, Ram A. Epidemiological profile of snake bite in South 24 Parganas district of West Bengal with focus on underreporting of snake bite deaths. Indian J Public Health [serial online] 2014 [cited 2019 Jul 18];58:17-21. Available from: http://www.ijph.in/text.asp?2014/58/1/17/128158
| Introduction|| |
Snake bite was included in the list of neglected tropical diseases by World Health Organization in the year 2009. , Snake bite is a public health problem distributed mainly in the tropical and sub-tropical countries. India is one of the high prevalence countries.  Though no clear cut data is available due to poor reporting system and poor maintenance of hospital data in India, 35,000-50,000 people die every year in this country due to snake bite.  Government of India official data showed only 1331 snake bite deaths in the year 2007. 
Very few epidemiological surveys had been done on the snake bite problem in India. To know the problem and to get some way out to tackle the problem, knowledge regarding epidemiological profile of snake bite is essential. , West Bengal is one of the high snake bite prevalence states of India besides Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, Tamil Nadu and Maharashtra. ,, In literature review, it was revealed that so far very few community-based surveys on snake bite was done in India.  Most of the epidemiological surveys on snake bite in India were done on hospital records. Furthermore, not much community-based surveys on snakebite have been done in the state of West Bengal.  Thus in this study, we made an attempt to collect the community-based data and also to evaluate the hospital data based reporting system particularly to point out the deficits of the hospital records.
The present study was planned with the following objectives: to find out the epidemiological profile of snake bite in eight blocks of the South 24-Paraganas district of West Bengal and to explore the under reporting of snake bite deaths in health facilities in that area during the study period.
| Materials and Methods|| |
This study is a community-based descriptive study with cross sectional design done in the period of January 2009 to October 2010. The study was planned in the South 24-Parganas district as it was the district where number of snakebite cases was quite high as reported for the previous 3 years among all the districts of West Bengal.  Furthermore, funding was available for survey on snakebite in this district. There were 29 blocks in the South 24-Parganas district of West Bengal. Eight blocks (25% of 29 blocks) were selected by simple random sampling for the study.
To assess the snake bite problem of the district National Rural Health Mission funded this study. "Canning Juktibadi Sanaskritik Sanastha (CJSS)" is a non-governmental voluntary organization working for public awareness on snake bite since 1986. Training of CJSS volunteers on verbal autopsy was done by the experts (Faculties of Department of Community Medicine, Calcutta National Medical College, Kolkata) based on the standard training procedure of verbal autopsy as laid down by Maternal Death Division, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India. Trained voluntary workers of CJSS started door-to-door visit with a set of specific questions. These workers of CJSS were specially trained to extract the history of mysterious common krait (CK) (Bungarus caeruleus) snake bite. They were directed to collect data of previous 2 years from the date of visit to the particular block. They collected data on various issues, e.g., the demographic factors regarding the victims, history of snakebite in previous 2 years, time of bite, healthcare seeking behavior after the bite, treatment history, outcome of the bite, any reporting of death. Totally 57 workers had done the survey in 1130 g sansads with a predesigned pretested proforma. Total number of houses visited by the workers in selected eight blocks were 381,853.
Data from the office of the Deputy Chief Medical Officer (MO) of Health II of the South 24-Paraganas district for the years 2008, 2009 and 2010 was collected. These data were the original broad sheet of the district containing several fields sent to the state authority. For this study, data on some specific points were noted and analyzed. These data were as follows:
- Total population of the district and of the eight blocks concerned.
- Name of the government health facilities (BPHC or Rural Hospitals) in the blocks.
- Number of snake bite cases who had attended the government hospitals in the blocks under study.
- Number of snake bite deaths reported from the study area.
Data from the direct survey and official reporting were compiled and analyzed by SPSS 18.0 version. These data were annualized (by simple averaging). Dividing the number of snakebite cases of the block by the block population we calculated the number of snakebite cases per thousand per year for the block. Similarly, the case fatality of snakebite and the case fatality rate of the hospitalized snakebite cases were also calculated. Then the case fatality rates as found from the hospital records and that found from the survey were compared.
| Results|| |
This study was carried out on a total population of 1,952,546 in eight blocks. Total population of the district was 6,752,294; so, 28.91% of the population of the district was covered.
From the survey, it was found that the total number of snake bite cases was 4871 and snake bite deaths were 184 in 2 years. Out of the total snake bite cases 3056 persons were male (62.73%) and 1815 (37.26%) were female. Out of 184 snake bite deaths 105 (57%) were male and 79 (42.9%) were female. 135 (73.36%) deaths occurred in the months of June to September, the rainy season in this part of India. 88 deaths (47.8%) were of the age group below 20 years of age. Deaths in above 60 years age group were only 6 (3.26%).
121 (65.76%) deaths were due to CK (B. caeruleus) bite. All these CK bites had the same common history of bite in the open floor bed. 62 (33.69%) deaths were due to Cobra (Naja kaouthia) bite. Only one case of death was due to sea snake bite. No history of death due to Russell's viper bite was found [Table 1].
|Table 1: Species of snake involved to cause snakebite deaths as found in the survey (n = 184)|
Click here to view
Only 22.19% of snake bite patients attended the local government hospitals. Out of the rest 77.8%, a small percentage tried to go to the sub-divisional hospitals, but majority depended on the local traditional faith healers.
[Table 2] shows the distribution of the total 184 snake bite death victims in the study period according to place of death. It was seen that only 26 (14%) out of 184 died in the government hospitals, 114 (62%) persons died due to interventions by the traditional faith healers. 23 (13%) died at home without any intervention. Nearly 4% of the deaths occurred due at venom stone which is a superstition followed in some parts of South 24-Parganas where a piece of stone is cut and bound to the snake bite site and the patient is made to walk with the belief that the stone would take away the poison.
|Table 2: Distribution of snakebite deaths according to the places of death as found in the survey (n = 184)|
Click here to view
Block wise distribution of the population is shown in [Table 3] which reveals that Basanti block was having the largest population among the selected blocks followed by Patharpratima.
|Table 3: Block wise distribution of the snakebite cases and snakebite deaths (with individual block population) as found in the survey|
Click here to view
In the direct door-to-door survey the total number of snakebite cases in 2 years in the selected eight blocks came to be 4871. Furthermore from the survey, the overall case fatality rate of snakebite from the selected eight blocks came to be 3.78% [Table 3].
From the 3 year records from the government hospitals in the eight blocks under study the total number of deaths reported in 2008, 2009, 2010 were only 20. Total 1622 patients of snakebite attended the hospitals in these 3 years. Case fatality rate due to snake bite from the hospital records came to be 1.23% [Table 4] which is much less than the case fatality rate found in the survey [Table 3] and [Table 4].
|Table 4: Comparison of case fatality rates derived from the hospital records and that found in the survey|
Click here to view
All the cases of poisonous snakebite are fatal if not treated. In our study the case fatality rate in hospitals are lower than the community. Thus keeping the two case fatality rates together we are getting a clue that hospital cases are better treated. Hence case fatality rate here is indirectly reflecting the efficacy of the hospital treatment.
| Discussion|| |
This study categorically proves that snake bite needs to get more attention. If compared with another highly attended public health problem, malaria, we see officially reported numbers of snake bite deaths are much higher than malaria death in West Bengal (340 and 96 in 2007 respectively).  This epidemiological survey shows that yet more than 75% of snake bite victims do not go to the government health facilities. They have strong belief on traditional faith healers. Grossly unscientific methods like venom stone application are still prevailing amongst the people of the district. The scenario had not changed in last 20 years; as we see in the previous study by Hati et al. also where it was found that only 22.14% victims went to hospitals.  Epidemiological studies on hospital data cannot assess the actual problem. A community-based epidemiological study on snake bite by Hati et al. was done 20 years back.  Research works on snake bite are concentrated mainly on clinical aspect; epidemiological aspect is still neglected.
In this study, we see case fatality rate in the local government health facilities (1.23%) are much lower than overall case fatality (3.78%) rates while Government of India data of 2007 shows case fatality rate as 1.73%. This is probably due to the time factor in treatment of snake bite. Early initiation of treatment by anti-snake venom (ASV) serum is the key of low case fatality rate.  Case fatality rate of a tertiary referral hospital of Pondicherry, JIPMER was 13.5%.  Hospital records of the Burdwan Medical College (BMC) of West Bengal for the year 2009 shows, out of 1424 venomous snake bite cases treated there, 74 died (case fatality rate 5.19%). This rate is also higher than case fatality rate of the rural hospitals of South 24-Paraganas district. It was found at BMC also patients came from distant areas either directly or referred from local health centers without any ASV treatment. In this study, we have seen much higher percentage of patients died due to CK snake bite (65.76%). As the volunteers of CJSS were well-trained about the mysterious CK bite, they could extract the actual cause of death by verbal autopsy. This mysterious presentation of CK snake is yet unknown too many MOs (personal experience of the first author in several training programs). Almost 100% bite in open floor bed by CK as reported in this study is similar with the observation in Sri Lanka and Nepal. , There is every possibility of death of a CK bite patient to be undiagnosed. Victims of CK bite hardly give any history of any bite; may present with pain abdomen, convulsion or sore throat only. , If the Junior MO posted in a rural hospital is not well-trained in the matter there is every possibility of another diagnosis than snake bite in these cases. In contrast, lack of training and confidence of the MO may lead to over diagnosis.  Almost all CK bite cases happened in the open floor beds. This data is similar with data from Sri Lanka and Nepal. , Use of a bed net while sleeping reduces this accident sharply and this issue should get proper emphasis during any public awareness campaign. Seasonal variation of snake bite deaths corroborates with other previous studies. Snake bite and death rate is always high in the rainy season.  This is probably due to flooding of the natural habitats of the snakes and rodents and their increased penetration in the human residences. Bites during agricultural activity which increases in the rainy season is probably another reason for high death rate in June to September Almost no bite and death in the winter months of December and January is most probably due to hibernation of the snakes. Death of 47.8% snake bite patients below the age of 20 years is a new finding in this survey. Other previous reports show maximum number in the age group of 15-45 years.  Sharp decline of death number after the age of 60 years is most probably due to less agricultural works by older people. Another cause may be less outdoor movement by the older persons after the evening. Though a reported death due to snake bite is higher both in the state level and national level, snake bite is still a neglected public health problem in the district.
| Conclusion|| |
Thus based on the above study, it can be stated that snakebite deaths were much more according to the survey than stated in hospital records. Case fatality rate (3.78%) as found in the survey was much higher than the hospital records (1.23%). Bites were mostly in the rainy season (73.36%) and by CK (66%) and only 22.19% of the snake bite cases had attended local PHC and BPHC. From the history of health care seeking of the snakebite deaths it can be said that lot of superstitions were prevalent regarding snakebite management among the rural people under study. In the present study, there is possibility of recall bias which is a limitation of the study. However, snakebite being a significant event in anyone's life chance of recall bias is less than any other day-to-day event.
CK was the most common snake to bite a human in the study which causes painless bite. That a painless bite from a snakebite can be fatal: This message should be given to both doctors and common people. Training of the rural MOs regarding snakebite management is required because snakebite can be managed at Primary Health Centre level only. Adequate preparedness of the rural health centers regarding snakebite management specially during rainy season is very crucial in this regard. Emphasis on early reporting of any snakebite to the local hospitals is recommended.
| References|| |
|1.||Warrell DA. Snake bite. Lancet 2010;375:77-88. |
|2.||World Health Organisation. Neglected tropical diseases. Geneva, Switzerland. Available from: http://www.who.int/neglected_diseases/en. [Last accessed on 2013 Jan 7]. |
|3.||Bawaskar HS, Bawaskar PH, Punde DP, Inamdar MK, Dongare RB, Bhoite RR. Profile of snakebite envenoming in rural Maharashtra, India. J Assoc Physicians India 2008;56:88-95. |
|4.||Warrell DA. Clinical management of snake bite in Southeast Asian region. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 1999;30:1-84. |
|5.||Government of India. State/UT wise Cases and Deaths Due to Snake Bite in India, Health Status Indicators, National Health Profile 2007 and 2008 (Provisional), Central Bureau of Health Intelligence: 126.96.36.199. p. 107-8. Available from: http://www.cbhidghs.nic.in/writereaddata/mainlinkFile/Health%20Status%20Indicators.pdf. [Last accessed on 2013 Jan 7]. |
|6.||Pandey DP. Epidemiology of snake bites based on hospital survey in Chitwan and Nawalparasi districts, Nepal. J Nepal Health Res Counc 2006;4:121-9. |
|7.||Hati AK, Mandal M, De MK, Mukherjee H, Hati RN. Epidemiology of snake bite in the district of Burdwan, West Bengal. J Indian Med Assoc 1992;90:145-7. |
|8.||Government of West Bengal. A module on the management of snakebite cases for medical officers. Institute of Health & Family Welfare, Kolkata 2012;1:3. |
|9.||Philip E. Snake bite and scorpion sting. In: Srivatava RN, editor. Pediatric and Neonatal Emergency Care. Vol. 28. New Delhi, Jaypee Brothers 1994. p. 227-34. |
|10.||Simpson ID. Snakebite management in India, the first few hours: A guide for primary care physicians. J Indian Med Assoc 2007;105:324, 326. |
|11.||Lal P, Dutta S, Rotti SB. Epidemiological profile of snake bite cases admitted in JIPMER hospital. Indian J Community Med 2001;6:45-8. |
|12.||Ariaratnam CA, Sheriff MH, Theakston RD, Warrell DA. Distinctive epidemiologic and clinical features of common krait (Bungarus caeruleus) bites in Sri Lanka. Am J Trop Med Hyg 2008;79:458-62. |
|13.||Simpson ID. Level of confidence of MOs in India and Pakisthan. J Trop Med Hyg 2008;102:31-3. |
|14.||Brunda G, Sashidhar RB. Epidemiological profile of snake-bite cases from Andhra Pradesh using immunoanalytical approach. Indian J Med Res 2007;125:661-8. |
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4]
|This article has been cited by|
||The timing is right to end snakebite deaths in South Asia
| ||Ravikar Ralph,Sanjib Kumar Sharma,Mohammad Abul Faiz,Isabela Ribeiro,Suman Rijal,François Chappuis,Ulrich Kuch |
| ||BMJ. 2019; : k5317 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Mortality due to snakebite and other venomous animals in the Indian state of Bihar: Findings from a representative mortality study
| ||Rakhi Dandona,G. Anil Kumar,Archana Kharyal,Sibin George,Md Akbar,Lalit Dandona,Brecht Devleesschauwer |
| ||PLOS ONE. 2018; 13(6): e0198900 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Snakebite: An Exploratory Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Adjunct Treatment Strategies
| ||James G. Kahn,Matthew Lewin,C. Soundara Raj,Benjamin J. Herzel,Tommaso C. Bulfone,Stephen P. Samuel |
| ||The American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene. 2018; 99(2): 404 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||A hospital based epidemiological study of snakebite in Paschim Medinipur district, West Bengal, India
| ||Sumana Sarkhel,Rituparna Ghosh,Kousik Mana,Kripasindhu Gantait |
| ||Toxicology Reports. 2017; |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Purification and Characterization of Nk-3FTx: A Three Finger Toxin from the Venom of North East Indian Monocled Cobra
| ||Diganta Das,Maitreyee Sharma,Hemanga Kumar Das,Partha Pratim Sahu,Robin Doley |
| ||Journal of Biochemical and Molecular Toxicology. 2016; 30(2): 59 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|
||Ethnomedicinal uses of plants for the treatment of snake and scorpion bite in Northern Pakistan
| ||Maryam Akram Butt,Mushtaq Ahmad,Anam Fatima,Shazia Sultana,Muhammad Zafar,Ghulam Yaseen,Muhammad Aqeel Ashraf,Zabta Khan Shinwari,Sadaf Kayani |
| ||Journal of Ethnopharmacology. 2015; 168: 164 |
|[Pubmed] | [DOI]|