|PUBLIC HEALTH EDUCATION
|Year : 2012 | Volume
| Issue : 4 | Page : 273-280
Landscaping biostatistics education in India
Ranjana Singh1, Sanjay P Zodpey2, Kavya Sharma3, Shrikant I Bangdiwala4, Suresh Ughade5
1 Assistant Professor, Indian Institute of Public Health, New Delhi, India
2 Director, Public Health Education, Public Health Foundation of India, New Delhi, India
3 Manager, Academic Programs and Adjunct Lecturer, Public Health Foundation of India, New Delhi, India
4 Research Professor, Biostatistics, Gillings School of Global Public Health, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, USA
5 Assistant Professor, Department of Preventive and Social Medicine, Government Medical College, Nagpur, India
|Date of Web Publication||24-Jan-2013|
Sanjay P Zodpey
Director, Public Health Education, Public Health Foundation of India, ISID, 4, Institutional Area, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi-110 070
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Biostatistics plays an important role in measuring, understanding, and describing the overall health and well-being of a population. Biostatistics as a subject evolved from the application of statistics in various research aspects of biology, biomedical care, and public health. However, with a recent increase in number of health and pharmacy related research, the demand for trained biostatisticians is also increasing. The present paper is an attempt to undertake a situational analysis of biostatistics education in India. A systematic, predefined approach, with three parallel strategies was used to collect and assemble the data regarding training in biostatistics in India. Our study results show that there is paucity of programs providing specialized training in biostatistics in India. Only about 19 institutions in India are offering various courses in biostatistics/medical statistics/health statistics/biometry. It is important to look into the current capacity building initiatives in this domain. Some other means for giving importance to biostatistics could be by making it a separate branch/specialization in a majority of the institutions, particularly in medical colleges.
Keywords: Biostatistics, Capacity building, Human resources, Public health education
|How to cite this article:|
Singh R, Zodpey SP, Sharma K, Bangdiwala SI, Ughade S. Landscaping biostatistics education in India. Indian J Public Health 2012;56:273-80
|How to cite this URL:|
Singh R, Zodpey SP, Sharma K, Bangdiwala SI, Ughade S. Landscaping biostatistics education in India. Indian J Public Health [serial online] 2012 [cited 2020 Apr 6];56:273-80. Available from: http://www.ijph.in/text.asp?2012/56/4/273/106414
| Introduction|| |
In the context of public health education, subjects, like biostatistics, which have an interdisciplinary nature, play an important role in measuring, understanding and describing the overall health and well-being of a population. Biostatistics is a subject evolved from the application of statistics; therefore, majority of the institutions, where existing courses in statistics are offered, teach biostatistics along with statistics, mostly constituting a relatively small portion of the course content. However, with a recent increase in number of health and pharmacy related research, the demand for trained biostatisticians is also increasing. Hence, there is a need to give proper and practically oriented training in biostatistics to people with relevant background. Against this background, this manuscript is an attempt to list various institutions in India that offer courses in biostatistics/medical statistics/health statistics or biometry to provide an idea about the number of people trained every year in biostatistics in India. This will in turn reveal whether these numbers are compatible with the requirements. Before analysing the current situation in India, this paper also tries to give a brief history of statistics in India and the evolution of biostatistics as a subject from statistics.
| History of Statistics in India|| |
India has a long history of applying statistical concepts in terms of data collection and its simple analysis, which got strengthened during the British period. The origin of statistics in India dates back to the Mauryan period (321 - 296 B.C.) in the Arthasastra by Kautilya, which explained the data collection system in agriculture, population, and economic censuses in villages and towns.  This practice related to the original field of statistics, the measurement of characteristics of towns or states. The practice of collecting and compiling data continued during 1590 A.D., in the period of Emperor Akbar, and during 1596-1597 A.D. in the Ain-i-Akbari written by Abul Fazal.  Apart from the population data, this document had the best compilation of data during that period with details of systems of legalized measurements, land classification, crop yields, and other information. This traditional system of data collection continues, depending on the kind of requirement; however, it gained momentum and got expanded during the British period.
The East India Company needed acquisition of counts and detailed information of their occupied territories, including area topography information, characteristics and conditions of inhabitants (including religion and customs), and assessment of natural products of the countries like fisheries, mines, agricultural yields and many more - mainly for the purpose of taxation and revenue generation. This compilation of information started in 1807 in India, covering a small portion of India only. The first systematic attempt to collect the information on the whole country was made during 1867 - 1872, which was incomplete. The first complete decennial census of India started in 1881 and since then, it is continuing with minor changes. Later, the need was felt by the Indian Famine Commission and agricultural departments to collect timely and accurate data related to agriculture. In lieu of this, a Statistical Bureau was formed at the centre (New Delhi) in 1895 and a Director General of Statistics was appointed.
Throughout the British period, the development in statistics was mainly geared towards administration, trade, commerce, and other such activities.However, an urgent need for appropriate statistical framework was felt immediately after independence in 1947 for the economic and social development of the country. Hence, Prof. P. C. Mahalanobis, an architect of modern statistical methods in the Indian subcontinent, was appointed as Honorary Statistical Advisor to the Indian Cabinet and a Central Statistical Unit was set up in 1949 under his leadership. Apart from this, some other organizations like the Central Statistical Organization (CSO) and the National Sample Survey (NSS) were also created to synchronize various statistical activities throughout India.
Although Prof. P. C. Mahalanobis, a physicist by training, is considered as the architect of modern statistics in India, the first Indian person with the formal degree in statistics was Prof. P. V. Sukhatme, who completed his Ph.D. in statistics from the University of London in 1936. Dr. Sukhatme, who wrote a book on sampling, devoted a good deal of his time and energy in popularizing statistical methods among the practitioners of agriculture, veterinary medicine, nutrition, and related sciences. He had also set up a research institute - the Maharashtra Association for Cultivation of Sciences (MACS), and started the Department of Biometry and Nutrition in collaboration with Pune University.
Another landmark in the development of statistics as a discipline in India is the establishment of the Indian Statistical Institute (ISI) in Kolkata, West Bengal, set up by Prof. P. C. Mahalanobis in the year 1932. The institute first started short training courses in statistics, which were attended mainly by the officers on study leave in government and other organizations from all over India. Later on, when this institute was declared as an "Institute of National Importance" in 1960, other courses like Bachelor of Statistics (B. Stat.), Master of Statistics (M. Stat.), and Ph.D. in Statistics were introduced. One of the main reasons for the rapid development of statistics in India was the close interaction between ISI and various technical wings of the Government of India.  In the mean time, the first post-graduate course in statistics as a separate and full-fledged discipline, and not as a part of mathematics or economics, started in 1941 in Calcutta University. Slowly and slowly, courses in statistics as a subject have been introduced in a number of universities and institutions, and today quite a large number of educational institutions all over India are offering various bachelors, master, and Ph.D. level courses in statistics.
| Evolution of Biostatistics|| |
Biostatistics as a discipline evolved from the application of the discipline of statistics to the biological and biomedical areas. It is a branch of applied statistics, which in early part of the 20 th century was primarily in agriculture and other areas of biological sciences. Biostatistics provides tools for the summarization and understanding of numerical laboratory and clinical data, including critical reading and understanding of the biomedical literature. It gained momentum in the twentieth century with the rapid advancement of medicine. Before the middle of the twentieth century, conclusions about human illness occurred mainly through the study of anatomy and physiology. Case studies or case series were common ways to 'prove' that a particular treatment was beneficial or that certain aetiology was the cause of an illness. Use of statistical reasoning for the above purpose took a while to develop, mainly because of differences in opinion among the physicians regarding the two approaches. However, with the emergence of evidence-based approaches, the need for biostatistical concepts was felt, which in turn resulted in greater use of statistical concepts in health-related fields. Globally, the contributions by Sir Ronald Fisher, Austin Bradford Hill, and Archie Cochrane for the development of evidence-based medicine were commendable.  With the development of epidemiology and information technology in the last few decades, not only the awareness and use of biostatistical methods in medical, clinical, and public health research have increased many folds, but the computational skills have also been enhanced remarkably. The INCLEN (International Clinical Epidemiological Network) consortium, in collaboration with the Rockefeller Foundation and USAID (United States Agency for International Development), has contributed substantially to the capacity building of biostatisticians working in medical institutions in selected developed and developing nations, including India.
| Teaching, Training, Research and Consultancy|| |
As far as statistics is concerned, the number of institutions offering courses in statistics is of substantial number and is increasing, but biostatistics has not been given the importance which it needs. All medical colleges in India do not have separate departments of biostatistics. At the academic level, in the majority of medical colleges, biostatistics is not being taught as a separate discipline even today. This constitutes a very small portion in the curriculum and many a times taught by instructors who are not trained biostatisticians.  During their study at the medical school, the majority of students does not give importance to biostatistics and only appreciate and completely understand the concepts when they complete their studies and start clinical practice.  Hence, to generate interest among medical students for biostatistics, it is very important to have effective teaching methodologies. Over the years, there are changes and modifications in the ways biostatistics has been taught, but still lot more is required to make the subject more interesting and applicable. It has moved from the conventional theory-based mode to more practical-based. However, there is still scope to include more practical exercise in the teaching of biostatistics.
Biostatisticians develop and apply statistical methods to scientific research in health-related fields, including medicine, epidemiology, and public health. They work closely with other public health disciplines to develop outcome measures to ascertain the effectiveness of programmatic activities and to develop the means to collect such measures, which may include surveys, lab reports, hospital discharge data, etc. Biostatisticians help formulate the scientific questions to be answered, determine appropriate sampling techniques and sample size, coordinate data collection and management procedures, and conduct statistical analyses and its interpretation to answer those scientific questions. They also play a very important role in the preparation of research material for publication.
Biostatistician's functions are increasingly becoming vital in the public policy arena as well. For instance, biostatisticians play a large role in informing policy makers about issues such as risk and protective factors affecting heart and lung disease, formulating new drug policy to combat infectious diseases, etc. By the next generation, biostatisticians are expected to be trained professionals fully equipped with the necessary skills for jobs in academics, government, and industry. In all these settings, biostatisticians are considered consultants to other researchers. , Teaching consultation skills needs to be an integral part of any applied biostatistical training program. Success of such training might be seen in terms of subsequent statistical consultations offered to the clients in worldwide settings. 
In the field of applied health research, many a times it does happen that a group of researchers start a study without including a biostatistician on board and involve them only at a later stage, whenever desired. If any problem at that stage is identified, which cannot be rectified because the major portion of the study has been already completed, then it becomes very difficult for the biostatistician to work out a reasonable solution.
With the above backdrop, the involvement of biostatisticians in any research study from the beginning becomes very crucial. Hence, availability of sufficient people with expertise in biostatistics/medical statistics/health statistics/biometry is very much required. This in turn requires that an adequate number of people be trained in these areas. An extensive search strategy was used to find out existing courses in biostatistics and related fields in India, details of which are given in the following section.
| Methodology|| |
The information regarding the existing long term teaching and training programs in biostatistics and related fields like medical statistics, health statistics, and biometry in India was obtained by using systematic search strategies. The Google internet-based search engine was used to get the list of institutions offering courses in biostatistics and its related fields. First of all, key words for the search were identified. The various key words used were: Biostatistics, health statistics, medical statistics, and biometry. The search was limited to the courses that are offered in India only. In the process of the search, information was mainly obtained on name of the course, name of the organization offering the course, location, duration of the course, eligibility criteria for admission, mode of delivery of the course (regular fulltime or correspondence), and if possible, the number of seats available. From the search results, short-term teaching and training programs of duration less than six months were excluded.
| Results|| |
Overall, only about 19 institutions in India are offering various courses in biostatistics/medical statistics/health statistics/biometry [Table 1]. As far as the regional distribution of these institutions is concerned, a majority of them are in the southern region of India [Figure 1]. Except for a few institutions like Banaras Hindu University, Amrita School of Medicine, All India Institute of Hygiene and Public Health and West Bengal University of Health Sciences, the majority of the institutions have programmes titled as Biostatistics. There is wide variety of available courses, starting from certificate courses, diploma courses, post graduate diploma courses, master's level courses, and doctoral programmes. An extensive three years fellowship program in biostatistics is being offered by Sanjay Gandhi Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, in Lucknow, which gives a rigorous training including both theory and practical, and also on handling a variety of statistical software.
|Table 1: Matrix of existing courses in Biostatistics and its related field in India|
Click here to view
|Figure 1: Regional distribution of various institutions offering courses in biostatistics and its related fields in India|
Click here to view
With the exception of Manipal University, Sardar Patel University, and Global Institute of Medical Sciences, Baroda, which offer six months certificate courses, all other institutes are offering programmes of duration one year or more. All diploma, post-graduate diploma, and M.Phil. courses are of one year duration, master's level courses are of two years duration, and duration for doctoral level programmes are three years and above. Out of all the available institutions, the majority of them run fulltime courses, which is very much required because a subject like biostatistics is better understood when taught face-to-face with lots of discussion and hands-on experience of data analysis by using some statistical software. Cliniminds, a clinical research training institute, runs various post-graduate and advanced post-graduate diploma programs in biostatistics and its related field. These programs are mainly run either as regular weekends or in a distance learning mode, considering the target audience is working individuals. There are institutes in India like Christian Medical College, Vellore, which offers regular training programs of short duration (from three days to one week) in various topics in biostatistics. Short-term training workshops are also organized for building capacity in analysis skills by using some statistical software like STATA, SAS or SPSS.
The eligibility criterion for admission to post-graduate courses varies according to the type of program and also, to a certain extent, from one institution to another. It ranges from a minimum of recognized bachelor's degree with medical subject or any other subject with mathematics or statistics as one of the subjects, to a maximum of master's degree in the field of statistics, depending on the type of course. Doctoral programs have the requirement that students who apply for the course should have a post-graduate degree in statistics or its related branches like biostatistics, medical statistics, health statistics, biometry, etc. For the majority of the master's level programs, a candidate should have a bachelor's degree with mathematics or statistics as the main subjects. However, the M.Sc. course of SRM University, Tamil Nadu, requires a graduate in medicine, AYUSH (Ayurveda, Yoga, Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha, and Homeopathy), engineering, pharmacy, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, dentistry, and arts and science with mathematics at higher secondary level, for admission in the program. The post-graduate diploma course of the Indian Institute of Public Health, Hyderabad has a requirement of a bachelor's degree in any discipline. However, Madurai Kamraj University, Tamil Nadu, requires a candidate with degree in science having mathematics as one of the subjects in 12 th grade. Diploma in health statistics courses in various institutions have the criteria of selecting individuals with bachelor's degree (either medical or B.A./B.Sc. with mathematics or statistics as one of the subjects).
| Discussion|| |
Biostatistics, being an interdisciplinary subject, is of immense importance in the vast majority of the researches that are being undertaken in the field of health sciences. This manuscript listed the existing institutes and organizations in India, which offers courses in biostatistics and its related field. It cannot be denied that researchers and medical students do need training in biostatistics for better, critical understanding of the biomedical literature and for conducting any research study. With the rising number of researches in the field of health sciences, there is an increase in demand of researchers with biostatistics training. There is also a great need for formally training statisticians in biostatistics applied methodology. Considering the growing need of biostatisticians in health sciences, the University of Poona took the initiative in the 1970s by starting a full-time four-semester interdisciplinary course in mathematics, statistics, and biology i.e. M.Sc. Biometry. In view of this, when we look on the existing courses and training in biostatistics and its related field, the numbers are not satisfactory, and it emerges that still there is a need to increase specialized courses in biostatistics, especially in the northern region. In the majority of the medical colleges, it is taught as a part of preventive and social medicine course rather than as a separate discipline. It has been found that among the medical colleges, biostatistics is considered to be one of those subjects which students dislike the most.  It is important to look for the reasons as why the motivation behind learning biostatistics is very low.
With the emergence of evidence based medicine, the demand for application of biostatistics is increasing in India, but this is not in tune with the number of biostatisticians produced. With the personal experience of the first author, it seems that vacancies for a biostatistician in general are not filled very easily. Most of the time, only a few candidates appear for the interviews. The possible reasons for this can be the availability of small numbers of trained persons in the area. Over time, the number of institutions offering courses in medical statistics is increasing gradually; however, the number of teachers is very few. In the majority of medical colleges, biostatistics is been taught by faculty who are not trained biostatisticians. Although the system of teaching is gradually changing from a purely theoretical approach to a more practical approach, there still is a need to be more innovative in teaching biostatistics by taking real life examples to attract students.
Teaching future applied biostatisticians requires teaching consultation skills. Teaching statistical consultancy not only involves statistical methodological training but should also focus on improving interpersonal communication and negotiation skills.  Hence, the job of biostatistics faculties becomes more crucial to generate interest and motivate researchers and students to understand the need for the study of biostatistics and its appropriate use.The other means for giving importance to biostatistics is by making it a separate branch/specialization in a majority of the institutions, particularly in medical colleges.
| References|| |
|1.||Ghosh JK, Maiti P, Rao TJ, Sinha BK. Evolution of Statistics in India. International Statistical Review 1999;67(Suppl 1):13-34. |
|2.||Mayer D. A brief history of medicine and statistics, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Available from: http://assets.cambridge.org/97805218/32618/excerpt/9780521832618_excerpt.pdf. [Last cited on 2011 Aug23]. |
|3.||Asif H, Asim B, Awais M. Importance and understanding of Bio-statistics among post graduate students at King Edward Medical University Lahore- Pakistan. Annals of King Edward Medical University, 2009: 15:107-110. |
|4.||Mostert P. Changing approaches and perceptions: Biostatistics and its role in teaching the Stellenbosch doctor; In the proceedings of Seventh International Conference on the Teaching of Statistics (ICOTS-7), 2006. |
|5.||Bross IDJ. The role of the statistician: Scientist or shoe clerk. American Statistician 1974; 28:126-127. |
|6.||Kirk RE. Statistical consulting in a university: Dealing with people and other challenges, American Statistician 1991; 45:28-34. |
|7.||Bangdiwala SI. Teaching Consultancy through Direct Experience in Research: The Approach of the Department of Biostatistics at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill 2002; ICOTS6. |
|8.||Doctor of Philosophy in Biostatistics, National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Science, Banglore, Karnataka. Available from: http://www.nimhans.kar.nic.in/aca_admission/prosp201112.pdf. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 23] |
|9.||Doctor of Philosophy in Biostatistics, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi. Available from: http://www.aiims.edu/aiims/departments/Biostatistics/Biocourses.htm. [Last cited on 2011 Sep 10]. |
|10.||Fellowship in Biostatistics, Sanjay Gandhi Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh. Available from: http://www.sgpgi.ac.in/biostat/fellowship.html. [Last cited on 2011 Sep 28]. |
|11.||Master of Science in Biostatistics, St. Thomas College, Kottayam, Kerala. Available from: http://stcp.ac.in/stcp/pgclass.htm. [Last cited on 2011 Oct 23]. |
|12.||Master of Science in Biostatistics, Smt. Devkunvar Nanalal Bhatt Vaishnav College for Women, Chennai. Available from: http://www.sdnbvc.com/sdnbvc/website2011/htmls/depart_mscbio.htm. [Last cited on 2011 Nov 4] |
|13.||Master of Science in Biostatistics, Christian Medical College, Vellore, Tamilnadu. Available from: http://www.cmc-biostatistics.ac.in/MSc_Brouchur.pdf. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 29]. |
|14.||Master of Science in Biostatistics, Manipal University, Manipal, Karnataka. Available from: http://www.manipal.edu/Institutions/UniversityDepartments/Statistics/Courses/PostGraduate/Pages/MasterofScienceinBiostatistics.aspx. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 05]. |
|15.||Certificate course in Biostatistics, epidemiology and research methodology, Manipal University, Manipal, Karnataka. Available from: http://www.manipal.edu/Institutions/UniversityDepartments/Statistics/Courses/CertificateCourses/Pages/CertificateinBERM.aspx. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 29]. |
|16.||Master of Arts/Sciences in Biostatistics, University of Lucknow, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh. Available from: http://www.lkouniv.ac.in/biostats.pdf. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 10]. |
|17.||Master of Science in Biostatistics and Epidemiology, SRM University, Chennai, Tamil Nadu. Available from: http://www.srmuniv.ac.in/medicine.php?page=public_health/mph_course_material#3. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 26]. |
|18.||M Sc in Medical Statistics, Amrita School of Medicine, Kochi, Kerala. Available from: http://aims.amrita.edu/school-of-medicine/departments.php. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 26]. |
|19.||MSc in Health Statistics, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh. Available from: http://bhu.ac.in/education/pg.pdf. [Last cited on 2011 Jul 30]. |
|20.||M Sc in Ecology Biostatistics and Taxonomy, Berhampur University, Berhampur, Orrisa. Available from: http://bamu.nic.in/. [Last cited on 2011 Jul 20]. |
|21.||Post Graduate Diploma in Biostatistics and Data Management, Indian Institute of Public Health, Hyderabad, AP. Available from: http://www.phfi.org/our-activities/academic-programmes/courses-a-admissions/142. [Last cited on 2011 Jul 28]. |
|22.||Various short courses in Biostatistics, Cliniminds, Academy for Clinical Research and Training Management, Noida, UP. Available from: http://www.cliniminds.com/presentation/Course.aspx. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 29]. |
|23.||Post Graduate Diploma in Biostatistics, Madurai Kamarj University, Tamil Nadu. Available from: http://www.maduraikamarajuniversity.co.in/PGdiploma-courses.php. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 14]. |
|24.||Diploma in Health Statistics, West Bengal University of Health Sciences, Kolkata. Available from: http://www.indiastudycenter.com/Univ/States/WB/The-West-Bengal-University-Health-Sciences/Courses/Diploma-Courses/DHeS.asp. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 29]. |
|25.||Diploma in Health Statistics, All India Institute of hygiene and public Health, Kolkata, West Bengal. Available from: http://www.aiihph.gov.in/html/courses.htm#statistics_doc. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 27]. |
|26.||Diploma/certificate in Biostatistics and Research Methodology, Global Institute of Medical Sciences, Baroda, Gujarat. Available from: http://gimsindia.hpage.com/. [Last cited on 2011 July 30]. |
|27.||Certificate course in Biostatistics, Sardar Patel University, Vallabh Vidyanagar, Gujarat.Available from: http://www.spuvvn.edu/academics/departments/statistics/academic_programmes.php. [Last cited on 2011 Aug 29]. |